A Big Deal
Since last August, Gartner released several dozen presentations on Pattern-Based Strategy. I find this topic absolutely brilliant. So much so that I tweeted, blogged (on my old blog), and presented on the subject. In fact, recently I had the opportunity to present at The Gartner IT Symposium/Xpo in Orlando last October. It’s a huge show with with gold star presenters like Eric Schmidt, Chairman and CEO or Google, and Mark Hurd, Chairman and CEO or HP. I’ve attended the show in the past, but last year’s was by far the best. My breakout session, “5 Steps to Pattern-Based Strategies,” drew a large crowd. We actually had to turn people away and some decided to sit on the floor! Keep in mind that 30% of the audience are CIOs. Therefore, I’m not the only one that cares about this topic!
Surprisingly, in my many presentations on Pattern-Based Strategy, I’ve come to realize that very few people actually know what it is. The name doesn’t provide much detail. If anything, it creates more confusion. In roundtable discussions I had at the BPM Summit earlier this year, I realized that how it’s presented usually leaves people feeling overwhelmed or underwhelmed. Some see that there is so much material out there that they don’t know where to start. Others, see a bunch of metrics and dimensions and wonder why this is such a big deal.
What is Pattern-Based Strategy?
Therefore, I will do my best to demystify the subject and share how decision management can be used with this approach. To begin, let’s start with Gartner’s definition: Pattern-Based Strategy is a “discipline that enables enables business leaders to seek, amplify, examine and exploit new business patterns. A business pattern is a set of recurring and/or related elements (business activities, events, weak or strong signals) that indicates a business opportunity or threat.” Now let’s break it down.
Is Pattern-Based Strategy a New Approach?
Not really. Many of its concepts are common sense and what makes it brilliant! Pattern-Based Strategy (which I will now refer to as PBS although that is not the conventional acronym) articulates what we already know in a systematic way that can be applied to just about anything. Whether your building an application, deploying an enterprise system, or setting your personal goals, PBS can help you do so effectively. We’ve all done a SWOT Analysis before, but that is usually a once in a blue moon activity reserved for launching a new business, product, or service. PBS is about setting up yourself or your organization in a manner where you can continuously monitor and respond to incoming opportunities and threats.
4 Pillars of PBS
First, according to Gartner, there are 4 pillars that are essential for the implementation of PBS:
1) Seeking Patterns
We are bombarded by data streams… Some are datapoints like your individual characteristics (height, weight, etc). Others are transactions like your credit card purchases. And still others are trends like stock market tickers. We pay attention to some of that data while ignoring others. For example, as a parent, I regularly monitor how well my kids are doing in Math. However, living in California, I don’t pay close attention to the weather forecast (earthquakes and forest fires are another matter). PBS is about uncovering patterns in larger and larger arrays of data, including the data you tend to ignore. Nassim Nicholas Taleb did a great job describing how black swans (very improbable events) can strike and have a far larger impact than expected modeled events. Companies that are able to identify and predict black swans are going to have a competitive edge over companies that don’t.
2) Operational Tempo Advantage
General wisdom, at least in the Business Rules world, says that faster is always better. However, with PBS, it’s more nuanced. Rather than “fast,” it’s more about “at the right speed.” While in many cases, as fast as possible is still the best, there may be cases where slower is better. For example, Talent Management. Companies that believe that they can switch a person or team’s responsibilities overnight will tend to drive dissatisfaction, poorer performance, and higher turnover in the long-run. With a PBS approach, HR would map out current and future workforce needs and create a roadmap to enable the organization to effectively evolve over time.
3) Performance-Driven Culture
Tracking performance is a precursor to seeking patterns, because patterns only exist as they relate to positive or negative outcomes. Therefore, creating a performance-driven culture should be a no-brainer. However, greater transparency is often a cultural hurdle to overcome. For example, in the never-ending Marketing vs Sales blame-game, each team blames each other for lack of closed deals. Sales blames Marketing for brining in “poor” leads. Marketing blames Sales for not following up on the leads. Enter the rise of Customer Relationship Management (CRM) systems to track and identify where the real missteps and drop-offs in the customer funnel are happening. However, getting Marketing and Sales people to actually use the CRM and to enter information accurately is a whole other issue.
4) Transparency
Transparency is more than tracking individual performance. For example, having worked mostly with Financial Services companies, compliance is a big one. However, even if regulators aren’t requiring you to document your procedures and processes, doing so can foster cohesion and collaboration. I remember an Insurance company that we had worked with that ran an ad campaign targeted at a specific demographic. However, Marketing failed to communicate this campaign with Underwriting. As a result, majority of the applicants that responded to the ad either received very high premiums or were declined. If Marketing had included Underwriting in the campaign planning, they would have known that this campaign would have a negative expected ROI and scrapped the idea altogether.
Transparency should not be limited to the four walls of a company either. The new digital era is encouraging companies to be more “open” with each other. Many services now expose their APIs to let other individuals and organizations mash them up. Data sharing between organizations is becoming more commonplace too. Consumers are also demanding more transparency, whether for social, environmental, or political reasons. In general, transparency and trust go hand-in-hand.
You might me thinking that these pillars seem generic. This, I believe, was by design. Gartner does not prescribe how to develop these pillars and they will vary by your role, organization, and industry. I think the key takeaway is to think about your organization in these terms and then find ways to practice them.
A PBS Roadmap
Second, Gartner came up with 3 actions for implementing PBS. This transforms the 4 pillars into a single roadmap that I find makes a lot of sense.
- Seek: Start your PBS by building a framework that allows you to detect internal and external trends and shifts.
- Model: Next, model your business in accordance to your business objectives.
- Adapt: Then, build flexibility in your runtime systems to that you can adapt to internal and external changes.
This model is a more controlled version of how adaptation occurs in nature. Species evolve, randomly changing, until they reach an optimum level of capabilities for a given environment. With PBS, organizations can direct their evolution and intentionally select what changes to make when and where.
4 Categories of Business Activities
In addition to the pillars and roadmap, Gartner also created a tool to help companies prioritize where PBS transformations should occur. Gartner identified 4 categories of business activities:
- Defined: These are business-as-usual activities that are well-defined and often automated. For example, your payroll process. Just because they’re defined, doesn’t mean they won’t evolve over time. Remember when everyone still received physical checks?
- Exceptions: These are exceptions to the defined activities. Sometimes they’re known (anticipated exceptions) which are then usually well-define and often automated. For example, you might have a different payroll process to handle your international hires. Sometimes exceptions are unknown (unanticipated exceptions) for which you can’t really address until they happen. The more robust your PBS implementation, the more you’re able to transform unanticipated exceptions into anticipated ones.
- Creative: These are new activities that need to be tested and proved out before becoming defined ones. PBS can help you identify which activities to test and when to roll them back.
- Collective: These are activities related to the shaping of public opinion, primarily through the use of social media. PBS is integral to listening, engaging, and measuring impact.
This tool can help organizations identify where they are today and where they want to be and how PBS can help them get there.
PBS and Decision Management
One reason I found PBS so compelling is because it aligns so closely with Decision Management. While you can’t really apply Decision Management to everything, when dealing with decisions made as a part of your processes, Decision Management essentially follows the PBS roadmap:
- Seek: Start your Decision Management project by gathering and analyzing data. This can be done through business intelligence, predictive modeling, and other tools/techniques.
- Model: Next, model your decisions in accordance to your business objectives. Here, you can use tools like decision modeling, simulation, and decision optimization to validate your strategy.
- Adapt: Then, leverage a Business Rules Management System (BRMS) to build flexibility in your runtime systems to that you can adapt to internal and external changes. Here you can use techniques like Champion/Challenger to test multiple strategies while minimizing risk.
As you can see, PBS resonated 100% with the vision I created for Decision Management. In French, we have this expression “Les Grands Esprits se Rencontrent” which translates into “Great Minds Meet”. This means that while we started at different places, we came to the same conclusion!
Learn more about Decision Management and Sparkling Logic’s SMARTS™ Data-Powered Decision Manager
Go to previous post

